Blog

Consumer Duty outcomes monitoring: why the FCA wants evidence your actions worked

The FCA’s July review is clear that MI on its own doesn’t prove good outcomes. For firms whose poor outcomes trace back to people, that changes how training should be treated.

In July 2026 the FCA published its review of how firms monitor Consumer Duty outcomes. It looked at board reports and information requests from firms across the market, and surveyed 56 of them. Its central finding is easy to state and harder to meet: “Collecting data, listing metrics or reporting management information (MI) will not, by itself, show whether customers are receiving good outcomes.”

Instead, the FCA wants firms to be able to answer four questions. What does our information tell us? How do we use it to identify risks or issues? What action do we take in response? And did that action improve outcomes?

Where firms fall short

The first two questions are about data, and most firms have plenty of it. The last two are about evidence, and that is where the review suggests firms are weakest. In one example, a firm identified problems in its customer support and agreed a set of fixes, including staff training. Later evidence showed it “was still passing customers between customer service agents, and did not always resolve complex issues first time”.

Practitioners recognise the gap. When we polled 739 senior professionals at our September webinar with regulatory consultancy Square 4, only 14% said they could show a joined-up, verified trail from MI through root cause and action to improvement. Asked to rank where they would focus first, they put turning MI into meaningful action at the top, followed by defining good outcomes more clearly, and joining up competence and outcome evidence.

Training is an action, not an outcome

This matters most when a poor outcome comes down to people: what colleagues know, understand or do. The usual response is training. But training is an action. Unless a firm checks what changed afterwards, it has evidence of effort, not of effect.

Square 4, an award-winning compliance consultancy and our strategic partner, carries out outcomes testing for firms. It finds that poor outcomes fall into two broad buckets: policies, processes or controls that are deficient, and employee competence that is not maintained. The second is the most frequent. As Square 4 puts it: “The primary failure we do still see is colleague failures.” Colleagues pass their training, but knowledge fades, and complex customer conversations are where the gaps show.

Yet when we asked 470 professionals in April, only 6% said they systematically link staff learning with outcome testing. The FCA’s good practice examples show what closing the loop looks like. Where staff capability caused poor outcomes, firms responded with targeted training, clearer expectations and ongoing supervision, then “used the same reporting processes to evaluate whether their changes were improving frontline staff performance and customer outcomes”.

What this means

  • For senior managers: completion rates show input. Boards need evidence of what colleagues understand, and whether gaps are closing, so they can challenge rather than approve.
  • For teams and employees: support targeted where understanding is weakest, and a clear definition of what a good outcome looks like in each role.
  • For customers: gaps found before the conversation, not after the complaint, and problems fixed at the root.

A useful test

Take the last poor outcome your firm put down to a knowledge gap. Could you show what the gap was, what was done about it, and the evidence that it has closed? If not, that is the place to start.

Read the full Purple Paper: Consumer Duty: What the FCA’s outcomes monitoring review means for firms and their people, with 12 questions for leadership teams. Download the free guide here.

Improve your business with Elephants Don’t Forget today.