Blog

FCA culture expectations: why firms must evidence culture, not describe it

The FCA doesn’t tell firms what their culture should be. It does expect them to show how it works in practice, and training is where the evidence most often falls short.

Culture runs through almost everything the FCA did in 2026: the Consumer Duty, the Senior Managers regime, the new rules on non-financial misconduct and proposals on remuneration. Yet the regulator has never prescribed a culture. It looks at four drivers, purpose, leadership, reward and managing people, and governance, and asks firms to show how culture shapes decisions, behaviour and incentives.

That is harder than it sounds. In its July review of outcomes monitoring, the FCA observed that many firms emphasise culture and support it with training and internal communication, but that this “often amounts to describing a culture at a high level, rather it being how the organisation operates in practice.”

What practitioners told us

At our October webinar, hosted in conjunction with Ocorian, we asked 310 compliance, risk and conduct professionals how confident they were that they could evidence their culture to the FCA tomorrow. Only 11% were very confident. More than half (56%) said they had the data, but it wasn’t joined up, and 31% relied mainly on policies and training records.

We then asked which one thing would be hardest to evidence. Nearly half (46%) chose training that changes behaviour, more than three times any other answer.

Five assumptions that don’t hold

Our panel tested five assumptions that appear again and again in the regulator’s findings: that policy equals practice, training equals competence, governance equals challenge, MI equals insight, and action equals an improved outcome. Each can leave a firm believing it is covered when it isn’t.

Training is the clearest example. Completion records show who attended and passed. They don’t show what people know weeks later, how confident they feel in difficult situations, or whether anything changed for customers. As one panellist put it, nobody would board a plane flown by a pilot who had simply been trained; pilots are continually assessed.

What good evidence looks like

  • Define the behaviour: what competent, customer-focused behaviour looks like in each role.
  • Measure people, not attendance: competence, confidence and wellbeing, on an ongoing basis.
  • Give the Board insight: fewer, sharper indicators that show when something moves from good to bad.
  • Fix the root cause: when something goes wrong, ask whether training, incentives or process drove it, then check the fix worked.

Read the full Purple Paper: Consumer Duty Culture: What the FCA expects firms to show, and why training that changes behaviour is the hardest proof, with 10 questions for leadership teams. Download the free guide here.

Improve your business with Elephants Don’t Forget today.